Worried about your comic’s rank on TopWebcomics.com? Worried that your readers somehow don’t like you as much as some other comic’s readers, or they’d be voting you up?
Don’t be.
Chances are many of the higher ranking comics on the site aren’t as “popular” as you think they are. In fact, there’s a good chance that many of them are getting multiple votes per day from one or a handful or users using a little extra “help.”
How do I know this? Because we’re currently in the Top 10, and we enlisted some help of our own as part of an experiment.
A little over a month ago, Kam and I set out to crack the elusive TWC Top 10. We knew we had a decent number of readers and thought that if we posted a TWC exclusive story, we’d finally crack that Top 10 — or get close to it. And we did get close — but hit a wall.
After a few weeks it became apparent that no matter how much we begged for votes from our readers, comics around the same rank as ours would keep pace or pull just enough ahead to stay one or two steps above us without lapping us completely.
It was an interesting game, and Kam had a few days worth of numbers scratched down on notebook paper to “keep score.” In addition to the TWC numbers, she was keeping track of the comics’ Alexa ranking , as well as Sitemeter and Project Wonderful stats if available. What was interesting was that comics with relatively low popularity were pulling ahead and/or keeping pace with ours — many without any recent voting incentives and with a lower number of “favorites” from users.
Hmm.
So we started looking into the TWC vote logs of more popular comics and were seeing some getting votes at the rate of one per minute without fail. (I don’t care how popular you are, that’s just and insane number when you figure a very small percentage of your readers will actually bother to vote, despite the voting incentives.)
Double hmm.
So, without going into too much detail (to protect the guilty) we asked around and got a little black hat SEO advice. (Cue ominous music!)
First, let’s hear what TopWebcomics has to say about “cheating.”
Got that? As far as they’re concerned, anything goes except for using a bot. Good? M’kay, let’s move on.
You see, TopWebcomics.com is just a Topsite, and like any other Topsite, it can be tricked.
How?
Well, rotating proxy services for starters. There are many subscription services out there that allow you to use a “tunnel” to essentially mask your machine as being from somewhere else. Double or triple up on these services, and you’ve literally got hundreds of IPs at your fingertips every day. (Hundreds of IPs = hundreds of votes per day. Hundreds of votes per day = thousands per month. Got that? Good.)
Determined to follow the rabbit hole, we enlisted the help of some eager voters and set them up with a few proxy services. And — unsurprise — we started to rise, rise, rise.
Now, what we found when we’d actually gotten into the Top 50 or so was interesting. We’d see voting appear in “bursts” of hundreds of votes at a time in the evening or early A.M. Almost as if someone’s IP list had refreshed or a bot was programmed to vote at that particular time. More on bots in a bit.
Now that we were finally in the Top 10, we began examining each comic’s stats more closely. What was shocking was that a few in the Top 5 (not naming names) had relatively high Alexa scores (high = bad) and more curious, their Sitemeters showed an usually low unique visitor to page view ratio.
Meaning, whoever was coming in was just probably viewing only one page… i.e. .. they were likely coming in to their site and just clicking on their TWC vote button. Or a bot was doing it for them because it was programmed to follow that path — who knows?
(Now our black hat voting team was doing no such thing. They were voting only from TWC itself because we didn’t want our actual Sitemeter and Google Analytics numbers “polluted” by this experiment.)
Right. Vote bots. The only real taboo on TWC according to the site’s owner.
No, we never did enlist the aid of a bot to stay ahead. We refused. But I don’t think everyone did. In fact, some comics’ vote logs look a little too perfect — too rhythmic — to be anything but a bot. Even with the proxy services, mistakes were made (duplicate IPs) and the timing was sporadic. That wouldn’t be the case with a bot. Especially a bot that could be programmed to vote X number of votes at X time of day and to stay ahead of X competitor on the list.
“Now Kneon, what about those little avatars that block bots from voting?”
Horse puckey! It’s a glorified CAPTCHA and can be cracked just like anything else. Most vote bots even include a CAPTCHA cracker, like this one.
Yes, it can be done. You can “cheat” TopWebcomics.com. And I suspect many are.
Now that being said, we’re stopping our samurai proxy voting squad immediately and fading out of the Top 10. We’ve been to the top of the mountain, and it ain’t what you think it is. (Don’t worry, though — we’ll finish the “Rhen Faire” short story for our fans’ sake! Also, any legitimate votes are also appreciated!)
What am I NOT saying?
I’m not accusing any specific comic of cheating. We’re 98% sure there’s some hardcore cheating going on, and we’re reasonably sure which ones are cheating, but without undeniable proof, I can’t point fingers. (And I won’t, anyway, because we were wearing that black hat ourselves, even if only for a little while!)
I’m also not calling for a boycott of TWC or any such thing. It is what it is — an advertising and promotional tool. Those advertising on the site (and there are plenty — just look at that queue) are getting exactly what they paid for. Our TWC ads always generate traffic and are worth the $15-60 or whatever we paid for them.
Also, those in the Top 10 are getting some traffic, make no mistake. In fact, the only discernible traffic upswing we had was when we were in the Top 10. We added another 2,000 to 3,000 daily page views to our normal totals during our week at the top, so the temptation to “cheat” and continue to do so to stay on top is pretty great. It is worth the time, effort and cost of these services if you’re getting a decent traffic boost out of it.
I’m a marketing manager by day and “get this” so I’m not too terribly outraged by all of this. It’s actually quite common in the SEO world. Just go into TWC with your eyes wide open — it is what it is.
Now, what’s the domino effect? The domino effect could be ComicRank as well. I’m not sure. If you’ve got all those unique IPs coming in to vote for TWC through your page, chances are ComicRank will pick those up as new/returning readers and adjust accordingly. Also, Alexa seems to be affected as well, as increased page views account for some of the Alexa formula. Comics that have suddenly found themselves in the Top 10 in the last month or two seem to have jumped markedly in Alexa rankings. (Again, not ours — we made sure voting was done without hitting our page to avoid polluting our actual site data.)
What I AM saying…
Don’t sweat your TWC ranking. Seriously. I’d say it’s “just a popularity contest,” but it isn’t even that or comics like PvP, Penny Arcade and Questionable Content would be at the top. It is what it is, and your “rank” isn’t a true reflection of how popular and/or well-liked your comic is.
Now, we clear on all this? Good.
Now go make some good comics and build your audience, “ranking” be damned.
And if that didn’t motivate you, well, now you know the real secret to getting in the TopWebcomics Top 10. Have fun.